Superintendent's Notes

Report raises important issues, sparks discussion

The recent study commissioned by Booth newspapers and conducted by MSU Professor Sharif Shakrani on school district consolidation makes valid points about cost savings associated with consolidation of districts and services. Of course we are all wowed by the astonishing savings suggested by the study; savings of $612 million dollars a year has great appeal. The news coverage has sparked considerable discussion among parents, educators, and the community about the benefits and drawbacks of such consolidation. These are important conversations to have.

Between 1950 and 1970, school district consolidation eliminated 4,280 distinct school districts, so the concept is not a new one to our state. Since then the pace has slowed considerably with about ninety consolidations taking place. In the last ten years there have been a number of research studies that looked at the impact of school district consolidation. In addition to cost savings, these studies considered such topics as transition costs; the ideal district size; community involvement and identity; length of bus rides and the impact on young children. The impact of district consolidation on student learning is an important avenue for inquiry also.

When entering into any discussion of school consolidation, it would be important to identify what voters consider advantages and disadvantages of district consolidation. The educational delivery structure in our state is based in law. District consolidation can only be changed by a vote of the people residing in the districts, not by school administrators or even school boards; so it is crucial that we are educated on the many pieces involved in district consolidation.

In the area of service consolidation, there are endless possibilities to explore together. I am very proud of the progress and success we have experienced in this area. The collaborative nature of all local districts allows us to find creative ways to save money as we realize even better services at lower costs.

Susan W. Meston
MAISD Superintendent

Booth Newspaper Article Series on Consolidation